American Family Insurance We Get You Back on Your Feet

American Family Insurance

Insurance Claims Denied by American Family Insurance

Dealing with American Family Insurance auto claims adjusters is a mixed-bag. Sometimes, its adjusters are very difficult to resolve claims with; sometimes not. Although the automobile insurance industry is becoming much more aggressive in denying automobile insurance claims as a whole, "Am Fam" can be understanding at times recognizing pain and suffering or mental anguish in resolving bodily injury claims of injured persons. When it is not understanding and it tends to devalue the true worth of many personal injury claims and cases, which compels Shaw Law to file lawsuits and threaten a jury trial to get fair value.

Surprisingly, we do not see a large volume of automobile insurance cases with American Family Insurance here at Shaw Law in Indiana. Most often, we see American Family Insurance on slip-and-fall cases involving injuries at various McDonald's Restaurants throughout the State of Indiana.

These McDonald's "slip and fall" or "trip and fall" cases prove to be some of the toughest battles we endure on a daily basis. Part of the reason is that McDonald's restaurants have very thorough systems of inspection and cleaning of its restaurants. (Remember, the law does not require a "perfect" floor or parking lot for customers; the law only requires that the landowner make a "reasonable effort" to keep floors and parking lots or sidewalks free from defects and dangerous conditions).

Secondly, the American Family Insurance cases involving McDonald's are very difficult to win, due to the fact that McDonald's does not want to set a precedent of easy payouts for customers injured on its property. It wants to make the process long, tedious and difficult to discourage its billions of customers each year from seeking easy money for feigned injuries or insurance fraud cases.

See us at Shaw Law in order to correctly handle your McDonald's injury claims.

Even though we do not see many automobile insurance cases involving American Family Insurance, "AmFam" is one of the largest providers of car insurance in the United States. American Family Insurance, also abbreviated as "AmFam", is a private mutual company (meaning its owned by its policyholders) and focuses on property, casualty and auto insurance. A Fortune 500 company, its revenues were over $6.7 billion for 2008.

American Family Insurance's history began on October 3, 1927, when insurance salesman Herman Wittwer opened the doors of Farmers Mutual Insurance Company (not to be confused with the Farmers Insurance Group -- which is a different company) in Madison, Wisconsin. At the time, the company's only product was auto insurance and its target market was farmers. Wittwer believed farmers presented lower risks than city drivers because they drove less often and not at all in the winter.

Over the years, Farmers Mutual expanded its market and product line to meet the changing needs of its customers. In 1963, Farmers Mutual changed its name to American Family Mutual Insurance Company to reflect its broader customer base.

It is estimated that American Family Insurance company is the fifth-largest insurer of automobiles and vehicles in Indiana, trailing only State Farm Insurance Company, Allstate Insurance Company, Progessive Insurance company and Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance Company. Latest statistics show that American Family Insurance company insures nearly 5% of all automobiles that are insured in the State of Indiana.

Today, it is known as a major insurance company through its radio and television commercials that attempt to convince potential consumers that American Family "protects their dreams' by the purchase of insurance.

Although we have relationships with many adjusters of "AmF"am (American Family Insurance company) in Indiana, we still prefer to attempt to get fair value for automobile insurance claims of personal injury, including pain and suffering, by filing lawsuits. Many times we can eventually recover 20x (twenty times) or more money in settlements after the filing of a lawsuit compared to offers made by American Family Insurance in pre-litigation claims offers.

Contact Us Today. It's FREE to talk; and we never charge a fee until we win.


Read Our 5-Star Reviews
  • A Lawyer you can count on.

    “Shaw Law works tirelessly for you! I received much more than I expected for my injuries in a fall. Jeff is not only very knowledgeable he is a great communicator and keeps you informed and up to date. ...”

    - Kim
  • Not just the lawyers you need, but the lawyers you WANT.

    “The attorneys at Shaw Law are absolutely exceptional. From the consultation: which was much more information and help than any of the other (9) Law offices I consulted with, to the one-on-one ...”

    - Tristen K
  • Jeff Shaw was Very Professional

    “I would highly recommend using Jeff Shaw as your attorney. He is very professional and nice and cares about getting you the best results. He was very helpful in my case. He worked 24/7 to take care of ...”

    - Shelby Kunes
  • Attorney Shaw got me a fair settlement, much more than I thought we were going to get.

    “Shaw Law handled our case in a caring and professional manner. Attorney Shaw let us know what was happening with each step of the process. He was available to talk to us at any time. Including nights ...”

    - Randy & Kathy M
  • I Told Him He Now Felt Like a Member of Our Family More Than Our Attorney.

    “Mr. Shaw told me from the beginning that he would be willing to help me and my husband get justice. Through every step of the way, he explained what was happening and why.”

    - Stephanie B.


  • $5,000,000 Verdict in Indianapolis, IN

    Bicyclist Struck by Indianapolis School Bus (independent contractor) Awarded $5M by Indianapolis Jury (Upheld by Verdict, $4.4M Paid)

  • $3,040,000 Verdict in Gary, IN

    Blackjack Dealer Awarded for Slip and Fall on Ice in Trump Casino Parking Lot

  • $1,750,000 Verdict in Hammond, IN

    Child Dies in Fire, Landlord Failed to Provide Adequate Smoke Detectors

  • $1,460,000 Verdict Near the Ozarks of Missouri

    Sheriff's Deputy who Collides With Improperly Transported Manufactured Home Convoy

  • $750,000 $750,000 Verdict in Delphi, IN

    $750,000 Verdict for Lady in Golf Cart Struck by Drunk Driver Awarded by Jury in Carroll County

  • $750,000 Settlement for Paralyzed Man Shot at Indy Gas Station

    Man Shot and Paralyzed at Gas Station by Unknown Assailant from Unruly Crowd That Gathered After Murder of Person the Night Before at Same Site

  • $750,000 Settlement in Indianapolis, IN

    $750,000 Settlement Slip and Fall Indianapolis Woman Falls on Water in Produce Section of Indianapolis Grocery Store Breaking Leg.

  • $605,000 $605,000 Verdict in Valparaiso, IN

    $605,000 Verdict - Child Awarded for Facial Scarring When Landlord Failed to Cover Exposed Hot Water Pipe in Living Room

  • $500,000 $500,000 Settlement in Bluffton, IN

    $500,000 Wrongful Death Settlement in Bluffton, Indiana for Woman Killed When She Crossed Center-Line Into Path of Oncoming Speeding Semi-Truck

  • $500,000 $500,000 Verdict in Kokomo

    $500,000 Verdict for Woman Slip and Fall in Domino's Pizza Restaurant on Water (Reduced to $375,000)



  • Work Directly With Your Attorney

    When you call SHAW LAW, you get to work directly with Attorney JJ Shaw and Attorney Sky Shaw.

  • We Maximize Your Recovery

    SHAW LAW has obtained MILLIONS of dollars in compensation for our clients—and we work to get you your maximum results.

  • We Get You Back On Your Feet

    When you’ve been injured, it can feel like your world is falling apart around you. SHAW LAW is dedicated to helping you get back on your feet and recover what has been taken from you.

  • Fully Transparent — Guarantee

    We make sure that you and your family are constantly up-to-date with the status of your case. Call, text, email, or DM us at any time—and we will get back to you.

We Get You Back on Your Feet

Free & Confidential Consultations
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.