More. Simple. Results.


Insurance Claim Denials

There's an old joke in the personal injury business. What's worse than dealing with State Farm Ins. Co.?

That's right, dealing with Allstate.

Allstate started a litigation revolution in the 1990s when it decided that it was going to stop treating injured people fairly and begin to "low ball" offers to settle claims. It worked. Many attorneys just gave in or gave up and accepted the ridiculously low offers. Some were afraid to actually go to a jury trial and others were probably lazy.

Allstate continues to use a proprietary computer software program called "Colossus."

Colossus is a computer program that values traffic collision claims for at least half of the insurance claims in the United States.

Colossus was first licensed and popularized by Allstate in the 90's. Allstate went with Colossus because it wanted to make all claims follow a standard procedure. Incidentally, it happened to save money on payouts, too. The system also identified plaintiffs' lawyers who typically would not file a lawsuit and just settle for whatever was being offered.

There are two similar products widely used by insurance companies: "Claims Outcome Advisor" (made by Insurance Services Office) and "Claims IQ" (made by Mitchell International.) Mitchell also sells "Mitchell Decision Point," a similar software program that helps insurance companies determine if they should pay the doctor's entire bill in PIP/Med Pay claims.

Colossus' system has a proprietary and secretive system to calculate a series of inputs about the nature and severity of injuries into a "numeric" score of pain and suffering. There is nothing wrong with this idea if used fairly. But it was not.

After all, a jury trial does the same thing. But this computer program was used unfairly to "lowball" all plaintiffs with real injuries.

How Colossus Works

Colossus considers some preliminary matters before looking at your individual case like whether your attorneys usually take cases to trial or file a lawsuit or just accept a lowball offer.

It considers the geographic jurisdiction in which the claim arises for typical jury verdict size. Importantly, the program contains approximately 600 injury codes representing the various types of personal injuries that can occur. These injury codes have a "severity value" and assigns money for each severity point to each specific injury. It then calculates severity points to Plaintiff's claims. (But, compare its 600 different injuries to the over 12,000 ICD-9 codes used by healthcare providers to classify or categorize injuries.)

Now you can see where it ignores most injuries.

The original idea was to prevent a single insurance adjuster from putting her own prejudices and beliefs about the strength of a case into a standard system.

Additionally, Colossus has over 10,000 rules to determine the questions that the system will ask the adjuster to generate a payout.

However, insurance companies do not understand the 10,000 rules. Or the insurance companies don't care. They just know that they produce outcomes evenly in a way that advances their mission of paying out as little as possible.

After consideration of the attorneys involved and the venue, the system counts up the points and computes a dollar value. There is no question that a big value driver for the formula - and for juries, incidentally - is a permanent injury. They at least get this part right.

See us for the Colossus destroyers. When Allstate is treating you unfairly, we can help. We Get You Back on Your Feet. Contact us today!

  • American Association for Justice
  • Indiana Trial Lawyers Association
  • Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum
  • Avvo 10.0 Rating
  • AVVO Client's Choice Award 2017


Read Our 5-Star Reviews
  • Not just the lawyers you need, but the lawyers you WANT.

    “The attorneys at McKibben Shaw Law are absolutely exceptional. From the consultation: which was much more information and help than any of the other (9) Law offices I consulted with, to the one-on-one ...”

    - Tristen K
  • Jeff Shaw was Very Professional

    “I would highly recommend using Jeff Shaw as your attorney. He is very professional and nice and cares about getting you the best results. He was very helpful in my case. He worked 24/7 to take care of ...”

    - Shelby Kunes
  • Attorney Shaw got me a fair settlement, much more than I thought we were going to get.

    “McKibben Shaw Law handled our case in a caring and professional manner. Attorney Shaw let us know what was happening with each step of the process. He was available to talk to us at anytime. Including ...”

    - Randy & Kathy M
  • I Told Him He Now Felt Like a Member of Our Family More Than Our Attorney.

    “Mr. Shaw told me from the beginning that he would be willing to help me and my husband get justice. Through every step of the way, he explained what was happening and why.”

    - Stephanie B.
  • Your Law Firm Is Number One in Indiana. You Receive an A+ in My Book.

    “I was very satisfied with the outcome. Your law firm is number one in Indiana. You have a very kind, professional attitude that's full of compassion. You receive an A+ in my book. Thanks again for all your help.”

    - April H.


  • $5,000,000 Verdict in Indianapolis, IN

    Bicyclist Struck by Indianapolis School Bus (independent contractor) Awarded $5M by Indianapolis Jury (Upheld by Verdict, $4.4M Paid)

  • $3,040,000 Verdict in Gary, IN

    Blackjack Dealer Awarded for Slip and Fall on Ice in Trump Casino Parking Lot

  • $1,750,000 Verdict in Hammond, IN

    Child Dies in Fire, Landlord Failed to Provide Adequate Smoke Detectors

  • $1,460,000 Verdict Near the Ozarks of Missouri

    Sheriff's Deputy who Collides With Improperly Transported Manufactured Home Convoy

  • $750,000 $750,000 Verdict in Delphi, IN

    $750,000 Verdict for Lady in Golf Cart Struck by Drunk Driver Awarded by Jury in Carroll County

  • $750,000 Settlement for Paralyzed Man Shot at Indy Gas Station

    Man Shot and Paralyzed at Gas Station by Unknown Assailant from Unruly Crowd That Gathered After Murder of Person the Night Before at Same Site

  • $750,000 Settlement in Indianapolis, IN

    $750,000 Settlement Slip and Fall Indianapolis Woman Falls on Water in Produce Section of Indianapolis Grocery Store Breaking Leg.

  • $605,000 $605,000 Verdict in Valparaiso, IN

    $605,000 Verdict - Child Awarded for Facial Scarring When Landlord Failed to Cover Exposed Hot Water Pipe in Living Room

  • $500,000 $500,000 Settlement in Bluffton, IN

    $500,000 Wrongful Death Settlement in Bluffton, Indiana for Woman Killed When She Crossed Center-Line Into Path of Oncoming Speeding Semi-Truck

  • $500,000 $500,000 Verdict in Kokomo

    $500,000 Verdict for Woman Slip and Fall in Domino's Pizza Restaurant on Water (Reduced to $375,000)



  • Work Directly With Your Attorney

    When you call or text us you will get to work directly with our experienced and dedicated personal injury lawyer.

  • We Maximize Your Recovery

    Our firm has obtained millions of dollars in compensation for our clients and we work to get you your maximum results.

  • We Get You Back On Your Feet

    When you have been injured it can seem like your world is falling apart beneath you. Our team dedicates our life to help you get back on your feet and recover.

  • Fully Transparent

    We make sure that you and your family are constantly up to date with the status of your case. We even developed an app that you can use to track your case's status.

Let's get you back on your feet

Free & Confidential Consultations
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.